There is Something Terribly Wrong Here

c 05.06.2007 14:21
From Gipfelsoli Newsletter - Globalized Solidarity

An Open Letter to the Press
Rostock, G8 2007: There is Something Terribly Wrong Here
Here in Germany, as major protests begin against the G8, the world press is not looking beyond the story of the battle – a partial story at best – and asking how or why it is happening

Summit after summit, we have seen the same pattern in the media. The images of black clad protestors hurling rocks at police, the stories of senseless hooligans—those whom the government says should be punished and locked away.

These stories and images of street fighting do nothing but spread fear,criminalize protests, divide social movements, and distract the public from the story of the G8 and their unaccountable polices that are spreading militarism, poverty, violence, environmental destruction and climate change.

It is easy to condemn those who throw a rock or burn a car, but most of what we are seeing in Rostock is police blatantly provoking violence, using that same violence to justify ever more heavy-handed repression. Each day we are experiencing constant harassment, searches and humiliation imposed on us in the streets and on bikes, trains and borders, with no evidence of crime.

According to an official statement 13,000 police were present in Rostock on Saturday – all were well-armed and wearing lots of protective gear. There were small bands of police running into crowds, pushing, shoving and encircling protestors in a legally permitted rally. We saw nonviolent protestors who were trying to de-escalate the situation bludgeoned with batons and pepper sprayed.
We saw huge water cannons infused with toxic chemicals spraying
indiscriminately. Why is the press not reporting these acts of violence by the police? If violence makes such good headlines, why does the violence of poverty created by G8 policy go un-condemned?

Perhaps we might begin to understand if we look deeper. We may see that such violent confrontations have become a symptom of social and economic systems that values property over life, prisons over education, sprawl over sustainability, borders over migration, war over peace. We might see that it is in the interest of the police and the G8 to have such street fights, to justify the 90 million euros spent on security (in Germany alone). We might understand
that repression and the violence of police is designed to thwart democracy and silence dissent.

But we who oppose the G8 will not be silent and we not be stopped. We understand that things are terribly wrong and that without such protests our voices will not be heard at all.

For ongoing independent coverage of events near Rostock:
Indymedia ist eine Veröffentlichungsplattform, auf der jede und jeder selbstverfasste Berichte publizieren kann. Eine Überprüfung der Inhalte und eine redaktionelle Bearbeitung der Beiträge finden nicht statt. Bei Anregungen und Fragen zu diesem Artikel wenden sie sich bitte direkt an die Verfasserin oder den Verfasser.
(Moderationskriterien von Indymedia Deutschland)


This letter was signed...

by... 05.06.2007 - 15:09

* Lisa Fithian, Austin,TX / +49 17629799874 / /
* Logan Price, Seattle, Wa / +49 16092437902/
* Nick Simmons, Vashon,WA /
* Causten Wollerman, Denver, CO / 303.748 0922 /
* Eric Freeman,Minneapolis, MN / (speaks German)
* Ian Markson, San Francisco, CA /,
* Val Alzarga, Denver, CO / 31610647398
* Michal Asterweil, Chapel Hill, NC / 0049015774630929
* David Zlutnick, CA,
* Brandon Letsinger, Seattle, WA,
* Luke Rodeheffer, Rodchester, MN, (speaks German)

Heart in right place

UK anarchist 06.06.2007 - 00:05
Its a finely intentioned article, but its a bit muddle headed. The huge police presence is not to justify their speanding, it is actually based on previous militant actions at the G8. When the movment public declared it was going to blockade IMF and G8 conferences, the police did not initially take this completely seriously, but since Seattle 1999, they have. To say the polie are the main reason for the violence is true, but to deny the protestors have any intention of disrupting the summit is silly. To say the media is ignoring the peaceful side of the protests is also silly, it emphasises them regularly SO AS TO MAKE THE MILITANTS LOOK BAD. Many liberal groups are happy with this, despite an all-liberal anti G8 summit looking like Gleneagles i.e. totally pointless and ineffectual.

Put it instead in these terms: given the undemocratic nature of the G8 and the role it plays in organising the exploitation of workers and the planet, it is inevitable that it will be met with force by those who will not accept oppression any longer. The trusty political army of the ruling class - the police - will always be there to stop such efforts, and they have the the majority of blame if anyone is actually hurt, either cop, militant or pacifist. In actual fact property damage is not 'violence' at all, and the police can never stop that from happening anyway, they can only use real violence - beatings, gas, guns - to punish the rebels.

To recap: there is no point in trying to brush our JUSTIFIED militancy under the carpet. If the G8 is met with protests, the should be direct - and that is there fault. Nobody asked Rostock residents if they wanted the G8. Suggesting that the media is somehow creating false images is a bit daft when you have black blocks over a thousand strong.